No Signature Banners?

[Guges]

Seems like this forum doesn't allow sig banners. That seemed to be an integral part of the culture on the "official" forums and would love to see that functionality included here.

[ElectricPaladin]

Seems like this forum doesn't allow sig banners. That seemed to be an integral part of the culture on the "official" forums and would love to see that functionality included here.

Me, too, if it's possible.

[Arachas]

It's one of the choices we made when Data Sphere was created. We felt like the forums would be a lot easier on the eye without the myriad of images that were allowed on the CB forums.

But if enough people want it, we'll look into it. But don't expect half-page-long sigs, though.

[jherazob]

But don't expect half-page-long sigs, though.

Don't worry, i'll just add two tiny 10K x 10K photos of the moon, not much

But now seriously, the fact that CB kindly provides us with things like this

is enough to consider it. And where else are we gonna say something about a list?

[Guges]

It's one of the choices we made when Data Sphere was created. We felt like the forums would be a lot easier on the eye without the myriad of images that were allowed on the CB forums.

But if enough people want it, we'll look into it. But don't expect half-page-long sigs, though.

Half page sigs would be a little egregious. The CB forum allowed unlimited 780x110 banners.

I would love to see us be able to do single 780x110 banners. Maybe we should start a poll?

[Scarecrow]

Ill put a vote in for no banners. They took up too much space on the infinity forums, and made things look cluttered.

[Yashia]

Well, I can see that some banners are really ennoying, but the old forum had the option to either disable a specific persons banner (if someone really exxagerated) or disable all banners (if you really dislike banners at all). Maybe something like that would be possible here, too?
Or a maximum banner hight would do it, too.

I really don't want you guys to change your project into something else and I totally get that you wanne follow your own style, but I always enjoyed the cool / funny / creative banners "over there"

[jherazob]

The fact that you can disable them in your user options makes me hope that they're turned on, if you don't want them you can make that happen only for you.

[Maru]

Or a maximum banner hight would do it, too.

ye set this and enable them

[Guges]

Seems like banners with an option to disable would be the way to go to make the most people happy.

I hope something like this would be doable easily enough.

Definitely needs dimension limits.

[Cervantes3773]

I don't have a strong opinion on the matter, but probably lean towards "no banners".

/Yes, really.

[Claudius Sol]

I don't have a strong opinion on the matter, but probably lean towards "no banners".

/Yes, really.

But... Your awkward and suggestive banners will be forever unknown to the new populace!

[Levitas]

Oh please no banners, or at least keep them small. People use that space to put billboard size visual monstrosities that dominate a post more than the content. I'm all for waving the flag for personal expression, but the majority were/are just bad. They make scanning posts needlessly difficult.

[Ghost]

I wish for a no banner forum, I prefer my screen clean with clear informations..

[Cervantes3773]

I don't have a strong opinion on the matter, but probably lean towards "no banners".

/Yes, really.

But... Your awkward and suggestive banners will be forever unknown to the new populace!

I'm sure I'll find a way to preserve it somehow...

/Oh wait, it's forever saved on some image hosting site - I can re-post it whenever and wherever it's needed!

[Mob of Blondes]

Speaking of noise, please disable globally the "sent with my" which goes in the post bodies. I don't mind configurable signatures so everyone can see or hide at will, but not the nonsense that even polutes the search results.

[Solodice]

I don't mind sig banners so I'm all for them. Set up a max size so you don't get those half-page long ones (and whoever does those is already cruising for a bruising) and it should be fine.

[Splod]

Ill put a vote in for no banners. They took up too much space on the infinity forums, and made things look cluttered.

This x 10.

People often include useful links in their signatures to blogs and useful posts, I don't feel we should have to make the decision to turn off sigs in order to avoid pages being cluttered by garish banners.

I vote no banners.

[Hero of Man]

Another vote for the No Banners club.

[Pierzasty]

I voted for no banners and I'll keep my stance.
I'd be OK with limited-size banners if they were kept to the sigs (so anyone can turn them off with one option), but then again, that turns off all the other information as well.

[Curundil]

I do not like banners, but that's just my personal opinion. While I enjoy some of them where they appear, and some really gave me a hearty laugh, I find them annoying in longer threads, where the same banners appear after every contribution - one line of text, five banners, another line, two more banners, a written like, another banner torrent, then, suddenly, text without banners, but with some utterly pointless army list that contributes nothing to the topic. Meh.

If it comes to a poll, you'll probably find me in the "no banners" or in the "one small banner" camp. Or halfway between the two.

[IJW Wartrader]

If it means people aren't turning off all signatures I'll go for signatures without images...

[jherazob]

Two things to consider:

• You can set your account to not show signatures. This kills all banners even if they allowed billboard-sized ones
• phpBB can be set to limit the maximum size of images in a signature, and if i'm not mistaken, the number, so even if enabled they could be set to, say, the ones issued by CB for ITS, plus one more the same size

So, turning them on with limits, and setting "show signatures" as off by default for all new accounts should be a good compromise

[IJW Wartrader]

If you have new accounts default to "show signatures" being off, it'll never get turned on except by advanced users.

[Icchan]

I'm voting "whatever" because I've already set my profile to hide banners.

If you do enable signatures/banners, make it clear to everyone where you can turn them off.